Yggdrasil · Humankind

The Comb-Makers Connected with Hedeby

A 2023 study of ninth-century antler combs from Hedeby that points to northern raw material and imported combs.

Myth and literature

The story

Archaeological interpretation: a laboratory study of old combs gives a species for the antler, and the authors then reason from that to where the combs were made and how they travelled.

Hedeby was a large trading town of the early Viking Age, and its excavations have produced about 1,250 combs and fragments. A team sampled 49 hair combs of one long type, dated by style to the ninth century, and identified the animal behind each one from its collagen. Almost all were reindeer antler. Yet the antler waste left by comb-makers in the town is mostly red deer, and reindeer live far to the north. The authors read this as a sign that the early combs were made elsewhere and brought to Hedeby, and that comb-making in the town itself began in the tenth century using local antler.

Myth and literature · Context

What we know, and what we do not

What is recorded: three separate steps. First, the species: most sampled combs are reindeer antler, a measured result. Second, the place of making: since local waste is mainly red deer, the authors infer that these combs were made away from Hedeby, possibly in northern Scandinavia or another trading site such as Ribe or Kaupang. Third, the route: they link this with other northern goods at Hedeby and with contacts to those towns.

What is not recorded: the workshop itself, who made the combs, and whether they came by direct trade, through a town such as Ribe, or with travellers. The sample covers one comb type only, and the method cannot tell red deer from elk or fallow deer. No named person or single journey is shown. The study’s title echoes Ohthere, but the combs do not prove his route.

Historical evidence

The evidence

The study is by Muñoz-Rodriguez and colleagues, published in Antiquity in 2023 (volume 97, issue 395, pages 1233 to 1248). The team used ZooMS, a method that identifies the animal source of bone or antler from collagen, on small samples from 49 combs of one type. Of the 49, 44 were reindeer, 42 certain and 2 probable; four could be placed only as deer or cattle family, and one was too poorly preserved to identify. Reindeer made up only about 0.5 percent of the identifiable antler waste at the site. Because the layers at Hedeby are disturbed, the dating of the combs rests on their style, not on the soil they lay in.